You may also like
4.6
4.6 star rating
4.6 star rating 1441 Reviews, 58 Q&As Thank you for posting a review!
We value your input. Share your review so everyone else can enjoy it too.
Thank you for posting a review!
Your review was sent successfully and is now waiting for our staff to publish it.
Thank you for posting a question!
Please click on the link in the confirmation email we just sent you to submit your question.
Your question will appear on the site once someone answers it.
Your question will appear on the site once someone answers it.
- REVIEWS
- QUESTIONS
Filter Reviews
Ingredients Shade Irritation Lift Color Eyes
Volume Brown Quality Shape Skin Smudging ...
Results Value Length Cleanser Coverage Circles
Plastic Curl Looks Appearance Expectations Flaking
Ingredients Shade Irritation ...
Lift Color Eyes
More Filters
FILTERS Clear All
Rating
Reviews
Show 1441 Reviews
Rating
- All
- 5.0 star rating
- 4.0 star rating
- 3.0 star rating
- 2.0 star rating
- 1.0 star rating
Images & Videos
Clear All
1441 Reviews
Updating Results
Verified Reviewer
0.0 star rating
03/18/25
J
Janelle
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
03/14/25
I LOVE this
Review by Janelle on 14 Mar 2025 review stating I LOVE this
I stumbled on this mascara while doing a deep dive on 1930s makeup for the books that I write. Unfortunately I had a brand new bottle of mascara at the time and was NOT about to throw it away. So I waited to order this until I ran out of the other.
Keeping in mind the learning curve, the first couple of times were a little awkward, but my lash...Read MoreRead more about I stumbled on this mascara while doing
Keeping in mind the learning curve, the first couple of times were a little awkward, but my lash...Read MoreRead more about I stumbled on this mascara while doing
es look STUNNING and I adore the brush side. Eyeliner is a BREEZE 💛 I just wish the brush/spoolie was longer cause sometimes I paint my hand 😂 a price I willingly pay for the ease of it all. I fully intend to bring this with me places if I'm out and about for touch ups.
Top marks! Will buy again! Read LessRead less about I stumbled on this mascara while doing
On 1930 Cake Mascara, Eyeliner & Brow Definer
P
Pam R.
Verified Buyer
2.0 star rating
02/20/25
Doesn't show up at all
Review by Pam R. on 20 Feb 2025 review stating Doesn't show up at all
Doesn't show up at all
On 1930 Cake Mascara, Eyeliner & Brow Definer
D
Diane P.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
02/18/25
Still got best
Review by Diane P. on 18 Feb 2025 review stating Still got best
The most natural looking lashes!
On 1930 Cake Mascara, Eyeliner & Brow Definer
J
Jammie S.
Verified Buyer
4.0 star rating
02/09/25
Love the new packaging!
Review by Jammie S. on 9 Feb 2025 review stating Love the new packaging!
Works great still trying to get the liner right. But love it as a mascara.
On 1930 Cake Mascara, Eyeliner & Brow Definer
G
Gayle S.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
01/29/25
A fantastic product.
Review by Gayle S. on 29 Jan 2025 review stating A fantastic product.
For once, I’ve found a mascara I can wear without my eyes itching or swelling. It’s pretty in a subdued way, but it enhances my lashes. It’s just a fun product that works really well. Love it!
On 1930 Cake Mascara, Eyeliner & Brow Definer
G
Gabby
Verified Reviewer
12/30/21
Q: What are the dimensions of the refill itself, I have a vintage tin I would like to use.
Answers (1)

Bésame Customer Support
01/03/22
A: 1.5" x 1.5" x .25” inches
Was this answer helpful? 2 0
01/03/22
K
Katherine
Verified Reviewer
11/05/21
Q: SPECIAL HOLIDAY BATCH:
What's the difference between this special holiday batch and the usual black cake mascara, please?
Thank you in advance!
What's the difference between this special holiday batch and the usual black cake mascara, please?
Thank you in advance!
Answers (1)

Bésame Customer Support
11/05/21
A: Hi there! The Special Holiday Batch comes in a black design box with a purple tin.
Was this answer helpful? 1 0
11/05/21
M
Maria
Verified Reviewer
06/22/21
Q: When will you have the cake mascara in brown?
Answers (1)

Bésame Customer Support
06/22/21
A: Hi there! The Brown Cake Mascara will have a new batch next year.
Was this answer helpful? 7 0
06/22/21
K
Kathy
Verified Reviewer
03/24/21
Q: Can I get just the tin for cake mascara
Answers (1)

Bésame Customer Support
03/24/21
A: Hi there! Unfortunately, we don't have the tins available separately.
Was this answer helpful? 0 0
03/24/21
S
Sophia
Verified Reviewer
09/28/20
Q: Does this have beeswax in it?
Answers (1)

Bésame Customer Support
09/30/20
A: The Black Cake Mascara does not contain beeswax.
Was this answer helpful? 1 0
09/30/20